Choosing the right toilet paper is more than a trivial decision; it impacts your comfort, budget, and even plumbing. In the vast landscape of options, Sam’s Club’s private label, Member’s Mark toilet paper, frequently emerges as a top contender for value-conscious shoppers. But does it truly deliver on its promise of premium quality at a warehouse price? This article delves deep into Member’s Mark toilet paper, exploring its features, comparing it with competitors, and guiding you to determine if it’s the ideal choice for your household.
Understanding Toilet Paper: An Overview of the Market
Toilet paper, a household essential, has evolved significantly from its early forms. Today’s market offers a diverse range of products, catering to various preferences and needs. From single-ply utilitarian options to luxurious multi-ply varieties, the choices are abundant. Key distinctions include the number of layers (ply), the material it’s made from, and added features like scent or lotion.
The market features numerous brands, each vying for consumer attention with claims of superior softness, strength, or eco-friendliness. In the warehouse club segment, store brands like Sam’s Club’s Member’s Mark and Costco’s Kirkland Signature compete directly with established national brands, often positioning themselves as high-quality, budget-friendly alternatives.
Crucial Criteria for Selecting Toilet Paper
When navigating the aisles for toilet paper, several factors should guide your decision-making process to ensure you select a product that best suits your requirements.
Material Quality
The base material significantly influences toilet paper performance.
- Recycled vs. Virgin Pulp: Recycled toilet paper is an eco-conscious choice, reducing deforestation and waste. However, it can sometimes feel less soft or durable than paper made from virgin wood pulp. Virgin pulp often provides a softer, stronger sheet but has a higher environmental footprint.
- Pulp Types: Different wood pulps contribute to varying textures and strengths. The specific blend affects the paper’s softness, absorbency, and ability to break down in plumbing.
- Health Certifications: Look for certifications that indicate the paper is free from harsh chemicals, dyes, or fragrances that could irritate sensitive skin. Unbleached or chlorine-free options are also available for those with particular health or environmental concerns.
|
Our Picks for the Best Toilet Paper in 2026
We may earn a commission when you use one of our links to make a purchase.
|
||
| Num | Product | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper, 12 Double Rolls, 231 Sheets per Roll, Septic-Safe, 1-Ply Toilet Tissue |
|
| 2 | Angel Soft Toilet Paper, 18 Mega Rolls = 72 Regular Rolls, Soft and Strong Toilet Tissue |
|
| 3 | Eco Comfort Pack Bamboo Toilet Paper – 350 Sheets per Roll, 3-Ply Soft & Strong, Plastic-Free Packaging, Septic Safe, Eco Friendly (PREMIUM WHITE, 12 Rolls) |
|
| 4 | Amazon Basics FSC-Certified 2-Ply Septic-Safe Toilet Paper, Soft, 350 Sheets per Roll, 30 Rolls = 185 Regular Rolls |
|
| 5 | Amazon Basics FSC-Certified 2-Ply Septic-Safe Toilet Paper, Soft, 350 Sheets per Roll, 6 Rolls = 37 Regular Rolls |
|
| 6 | Charmin Ultra Soft Cushiony Touch Toilet Paper, 24 Family Mega = 123 Regular Rolls, White |
|
| 7 | Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Toilet Paper, 24 Mega Rolls = 96 Regular Rolls, 3X Thicker*, 3 Ply Soft Toilet Tissue |
|
| 8 | Scott Professional 100% Recycled Fiber Standard Roll Bulk Toilet Paper (13217), 2-Ply, Elevated Design, White, Individually Wrapped (80 Rolls of 473 Sheets, 37,840 Sheet Total) |
|
| 9 | Happy Valentines Day Decorations Gifts for Him Her Girls Women Teens, 3 Ply 150 Sheet Funny Toilet Paper Roll, Red Love Heart Tissue Paper, Friends Bathroom Toilet Themed Party Decorations Favors |
|
| 10 | Amazon Basics Soft and Strong 2-Ply Toilet Paper, 6 Ultra Rolls = 24 Regular Rolls, Unscented, 340 Sheet (6 Rolls) |
|
Softness and Absorbency
These two attributes are often at the top of a consumer’s priority list.
- Assessing Softness: While subjective, softness is crucial for comfort. Multi-ply papers often feel softer due to their layered construction and quilted textures.
- Impact of Absorbency: Good absorbency means you use fewer sheets, offering better value and reducing waste. A paper that is too thin or lacks proper absorbency can lead to using more product.
- Comparison: High-end brands typically excel in both softness and absorbency, though private labels like Member’s Mark are often praised for achieving a good balance at a lower price point.
Strength and Tear Resistance
No one wants toilet paper that tears too easily during use.
- Why Strength Matters: A strong toilet paper ensures efficient cleaning and prevents fingers from poking through, enhancing hygiene and user satisfaction.
- Testing Strength: You can gauge strength by gently pulling on a sheet; it should offer some resistance before tearing.
- Factors Influencing Strength: The number of plies (layers) and the quality of the paper fibers directly contribute to its durability. Two or three-ply options generally offer superior strength compared to single-ply.
Roll Size and Quantity
Considering the size and number of rolls can significantly impact both convenience and cost-effectiveness.
- Common Roll Sizes: Toilet paper rolls come in various sizes, from standard to mega and jumbo rolls. Larger rolls mean less frequent changing.
- Calculating Cost-Effectiveness: When comparing prices, it’s essential to look beyond the upfront cost per package and calculate the cost per sheet or per square foot to determine the true value. This helps in understanding which option offers more for your money in the long run.
- Matching Needs: For large families or businesses, bulk packages with mega rolls are often the most economical choice, reducing shopping frequency and ensuring a consistent supply.
Pricing and Value
The price of toilet paper can vary widely across brands and retailers.
- Price Segments: The market is generally segmented into economy, mid-range, and premium options. Warehouse brands typically fall into the mid-range but often deliver premium-like quality at a competitive price.
- Brand vs. Store Brand: Private labels like Member’s Mark often provide substantial savings compared to national brands while maintaining comparable quality. Many consumers find store brands to be an excellent balance of cost and performance.
- Smart Shopping: Buying in bulk from warehouse clubs like Sam’s Club can offer significant savings over smaller packs from regular supermarkets. Look for sales and coupons to maximize your savings.
Comparing Popular Toilet Paper Varieties
Choosing the best toilet paper often comes down to balancing comfort, durability, and cost. Here’s a general comparison across different types, including the prominent Member’s Mark offering:
| Feature | 1-Ply (Economy) | 2-Ply (Standard/Member’s Mark) | 3-Ply (Premium) | Wet Wipes (Complementary) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Often recycled or basic pulp | Virgin pulp, some recycled blends, PEFC Certified (Member’s Mark) | Virgin pulp, soft fibers | Cloth-like material, various solutions |
| Softness | Low | Medium to High (praised for softness) | Very High, often quilted | Soft, moist |
| Absorbency | Low to Medium | Good to Very Good (efficient cleansing) | Excellent | Excellent (moist clean) |
| Strength | Low, tears easily | Good, durable | Very High, tear-resistant | High |
| Price | Very Low | Mid-range (excellent value) | High | Varies, often higher per use |
| General Review | Best for budget, often rough | Excellent balance of softness, strength, and value. | Luxurious, but costly | Supplemental, not for primary use |
Member’s Mark Ultra Premium Soft and Strong Bath Tissue, Sam’s Club’s flagship toilet paper, is a 2-ply option renowned for its impressive balance of softness and strength. Many users consistently rate it highly, often noting its feel is comparable to more expensive national brands. It’s designed for efficient cleaning with fewer sheets and is tested septic-safe. Each pack typically contains 45 large rolls, with 235 sheets per roll, offering substantial value.
How to Select the Right Toilet Paper for Your Needs
Finding the perfect toilet paper involves a careful assessment of your specific requirements and preferences.
Defining Your Usage Needs
Before making a purchase, consider the context of its use.
- For Households, Offices, or Restaurants? Families might prioritize softness and bulk value, while offices might lean towards durability and cost-effectiveness. Restaurants or public restrooms often require robust, economical options.
- Prioritizing Factors: Do you value supreme softness above all else, or is strength and durability more critical for your family? Perhaps being eco-friendly is your primary concern, leading you to seek recycled or sustainably certified options.
- Special Requirements: If you have sensitive skin, unscented, dye-free, and hypoallergenic options are vital. For homes with septic systems, always ensure the toilet paper is explicitly labeled as “septic-safe” to prevent plumbing issues. Member’s Mark bath tissue is proudly tested septic-safe, making it a reliable choice for such households.
Thoroughly Review Product Information
A quick glance at the packaging is often not enough.
- Ingredients and Certifications: Look for details on material composition (e.g., virgin pulp, recycled content) and any certifications like PEFC, which indicates sustainable forest management. These details provide insight into both environmental impact and product quality.
- Customer Reviews: User reviews can offer invaluable real-world insights into the product’s performance, highlighting common pros and cons that might not be apparent from the product description alone. High ratings, such as the 4.9-star average for Member’s Mark toilet paper on Sam’s Club’s website, indicate widespread satisfaction.
- Manufacturer Information: Understanding who makes the product can sometimes provide an indication of its quality and ethical standards. Member’s Mark is a private label of Sam’s Club, which is owned by Walmart.
Where to Purchase
Your shopping venue can influence both price and convenience.
- Physical Stores: Supermarkets, convenience stores, and traditional markets offer immediate access but often at higher per-unit prices for smaller quantities.
- Online Retailers: E-commerce platforms provide a vast selection, often with competitive pricing and the convenience of home delivery, especially for bulk purchases. Sam’s Club’s own website is a primary source for Member’s Mark products.
- Bulk Buying Considerations: When purchasing large quantities, ensure you have adequate storage space. Warehouse clubs are ideal for bulk buying, providing significant cost savings over time.
Top-Rated Toilet Paper: Member’s Mark Ultra Premium
When it comes to warehouse club toilet paper, Member’s Mark Ultra Premium Soft and Strong Bath Tissue from Sam’s Club consistently receives high accolades for its exceptional value and quality. It is a 2-ply toilet paper that boasts superior softness combined with remarkable strength, delivering a complete cleaning experience using fewer sheets. This product stands out as a preferred choice for many members due to its competitive pricing compared to leading national brands.
Customers frequently praise its soft feel, durability, and effectiveness, often comparing its quality to much more expensive options on the market. It is also noted for producing less lint, a common complaint with some softer toilet paper brands, and is rigorously tested to be septic-safe. Each package contains 45 large rolls, each with 235 sheets, ensuring a long-lasting supply for households. The individual packaging of smaller roll sets within the large bundle also makes it convenient for storage and distribution across multiple bathrooms.
> “Member’s Mark toilet paper hits that sweet spot between luxury and economy. It’s soft enough for comfort, strong enough for effective cleaning, and the bulk pricing makes it incredibly budget-friendly.” – Sarah L., Household Budget Expert
While some Reddit users have noted occasional inconsistencies in strength or sheet count in older discussions, the overwhelming sentiment in recent reviews points to a high-quality product that rivals premium brands without the premium price tag. The consensus among Sam’s Club members is that it’s a worthwhile purchase, often cited as one of the best value items available at the club.
Important Considerations for Using and Storing Toilet Paper
Proper handling and storage of toilet paper are essential for hygiene, maintaining product quality, and ensuring efficient use.
Correct Usage for Personal Hygiene
Using toilet paper effectively is key to personal cleanliness. Always use enough sheets to ensure thorough cleaning without excessive waste. While Member’s Mark toilet paper is designed for strength and absorbency, using a sufficient amount ensures optimal hygiene. Dispose of used toilet paper in the toilet, provided your plumbing system is robust enough and the paper is septic-safe, as Member’s Mark is. Avoid over-flushing large wads of paper, as this can lead to clogs even with flushable products.
Storage for Longevity and Hygiene
Storing toilet
